What Is a Binding Plea Agreement?

••• Behind bars image by Warren Millar from Fotolia.com

Related Articles

Pursuant to Rule 11 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, plea agreements may come in three forms: charge bargains, sentence bargains and binding plea bargains. Plea agreements occur in criminal law contexts between defendants and prosecutors. When a defendant chooses a binding plea agreement, he is forever bound to the sentence to which he agreed.

Plea Bargaining Defined

Typically, plea bargaining is an agreement in which a defendant pleads guilty in exchange for a dismissal of, or a reduction in, criminal charges. Often, a criminal defendant will offer information about the crime for which he is charged including naming other participants in the crime. Once a defendant and a prosecutor strike a plea deal, the presiding judge must agree to its terms.


Plea bargaining is frequently deemed controversial, as it allows a defendant to negotiate his sentence. In capital murder cases, criminal defendants may sometimes negotiate for a life sentence instead of the death penalty if they agree to reveal specific details about their crime such as the location of a victim's body. The purpose for plea bargaining is to reduce the prison population and, in some cases, to give a victim's family closure when details about a loved one's death or the location of her body is revealed.

Binding Plea Agreements

Of the three types of plea agreements, binding plea agreements are the most specific. When a defendant enters into a binding plea agreement, his sentence is explicitly defined. Some defendants choose to enter binding plea agreements because binding plea agreements involve agreed-upon sentences, thereby reducing uncertainty. With other plea agreements, a defendant's sentence is ultimately decided by a presiding judge. Entering into a binding plea agreement may seem attractive to a defendant if he believes the presiding judge is apt to give him a harsher sentence.


When sentencing a guilty defendant, judges must adhere to specific sentencing guidelines. In charge bargaining and sentence bargaining, a judge must follow sentencing guidelines; however, judicial discretion is still allowed. Conversely, in binding plea agreements, judges must follow the terms of the agreement, which may bind a defendant to a harsher sentence. Another disadvantage to defendants who enter binding plea agreements is that sometimes sentencing guidelines are changed, resulting in a lowered sentencing range. Defendants who choose non-binding plea agreements may subsequently petition to have their sentence lowered. However, defendants who choose to enter a binding plea agreement are prohibited from later petitioning the court for a lower sentence.