Income averaging is a federal tax code provision allowing fishermen, farmers and some retirees to spread their income over a period of years rather than paying a large sum in a single year. It shields fishermen and farmers from the variability of their vocations, allowing years of low income to balance out years of high income. For pensioners, it creates flexibility in how they treat lump-sum payments from retirement plans. Income averaging was available to a wider cross-section of taxpayers before the 1986 Tax Reform Act, which narrowed the provision to its current form.
What Happens Now
Prior to the 1987 tax year, any taxpayer who experienced a large bulge in annual income such as from a huge work bonus or big sales commission, or a financial windfall such as from lottery jackpot winnings, could use income averaging to reduce his tax bill. Since 1987, the federal tax code requires taxes on an extraordinary income bulge to be paid in full in the year the money was paid, regardless of whether this pushes the taxpayer into a higher tax-rate bracket. The major exceptions are for farmers and fishermen, who are still allowed to use income averaging.
Farmers and Fishermen
Income averaging for farmers and fishermen works like this: They take this year’s big income bulge and divide it into thirds. They recalculate their income taxes for this year and the preceding two years based on one-third of the income bulge being posted in each of the three years. This effectively increases their taxable income for the preceding years while reducing it for the current year.
Under the graduated income tax system, the tax rate applied to these revised annual income figures would increase, but by much less than if the entire income bulge were to be taxed this year. The net result is to lower the total tax owed on the income bulge.
Income Averaging and AMT
Farmers and fishermen who tried to use income averaging to offset an exceptionally good income year sometimes ran afoul of the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT). The AMT is a parallel income tax system that doesn't recognize many of the exemptions and deductions of the regular income tax system. Taxpayers owe the higher of regular income tax or the AMT. But the reduced tax bills from income averaging put some farmers and fishermen into the clutches of the AMT, eliminating any tax savings from income averaging, states the University of Missouri Agricultural Extension Service.
Congress corrected this situation in 2004 by specifying that AMT liability must be compared to the calculated regular tax liability, not the lesser tax liability after using income averaging.
Read More: How to Claim Income Under $600
Another Income Average
Another form of income averaging exists for certain people who close out a tax-deferred retirement plan such as a 401k or traditional individual retirement account by taking a large lump-sum distribution. People born before January 2, 1936 who have been in their tax-deferred retirement plan for at least five years and who take out the entire balance in their plan in a single distribution, may be able to use 10-year income averaging to spread the tax bite over a 10-year span. The IRS would assume the account balance was paid in 10 equal annual installments and set the annual tax liability accordingly.
Averaging For the Self Employed
The Internal Revenue Service, at its option, may permit income averaging for delinquent taxpayers who are commissioned salespeople, self-employed people or those whose income is wholly at the mercy of the market for their trade. Permission to use forward income averaging is granted or denied on a case-by-case basis, depending on the IRS’ judgment call of whether current earnings or average earnings history better represents the taxpayer's earning capacity.
- FinancialDictionary.com: Income Averaging
- U.S. Internal Revenue Service: Schedule J (Form 1040), Income Averaging for Farmers and Fishermen
- U.S. Internal Revenue Service: Tax Topics #412 -- Lump-Sum Distributions
- TurboTax: What Is Schedule J: Income Averaging for Farmers and Fishermen
- 2019 Instructions for Schedule J (2019) | Internal Revenue Service
- Fouts Law Group: What is Income Averaging and How is it Used by the IRS?
Herb Kirchhoff has more than three decades of hands-on experience as an avid garden hobbyist and home handyman. Since retiring from the news business in 2008, Kirchhoff takes care of a 12-acre rural Michigan lakefront property and applies his experience to his vegetable and flower gardens and home repair and renovation projects.