Bankruptcy is a legal process by which debtors may restructure or obtain relief from overwhelming debts and get a fresh start on building a positive economic future. The bankruptcy court process has stringent rules and timelines to insure the debtor and creditors are treated fairly. Failure to abide by these rules may lead to dismissal of the bankruptcy, but in most instances, the debtor will be allowed to refile.
Dismissal vs. Discharge
A discharge is the final court action sought by a debtor in a bankruptcy proceeding, as it signals the bankruptcy is over. The discharge is the court order stating that all repayment obligations have been met, and precludes creditors from continuing to pursue collection. A bankruptcy dismissal, on the other hand, is ordinarily a highly undesirable turn of events for the debtor. When the bankruptcy court dismisses a bankruptcy proceeding, it means that the bankruptcy is void and creditors can immediately return to their collection actions and proceed with attachment of property, wage garnishment and any other lawful means of collection.
Reasons for Dismissal
A notice of dismissal of a bankruptcy case usually arises when the debtor has failed to meet a deadline or fulfill his obligations. Common reasons for dismissal include filing errors or missed filing deadlines, failing to appear at the 314 meeting of creditors, and failure to make monthly payments under a Chapter 13 repayment plan. It is important to swiftly and clearly determine the reason for the dismissal, as some dismissal grounds--such as failure to attend a required credit counseling course--will preclude reinstatement.
Read More: How to Do a Chapter 13 Dismissal
Motion to Reinstate
In some circumstances, the debtor may file a motion to reinstate a bankruptcy case. The reinstatement motion must be filed swiftly, usually within ten business days of the dismissal, although that deadline may vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction depending on the local bankruptcy court rules. The court may require all circumstances that led to the dismissal be rectified prior to granting reinstatement. For example, if the dismissal was due to missed payments under a Chapter 13 debt restructuring plan, the court may require the missing payments be made up before reinstating the case.
Refiling Chapters 7 and 13
If swift reinstatement of the bankruptcy is not possible, the debtor may be able to re-file and start over at a later date. Dismissal will not prevent debts from being discharged later or prejudice the debtor in a later bankruptcy proceeding. If the bankruptcy was dismissed voluntarily, or dismissed due to the debtor's failure to appear in court or for a 314 meeting, the debtor will have to wait 180 days before refiling. If you are refiling a Chapter 13, you will have to qualify once again for the Chapter 13 process based on your financial circumstances at the time of refiling. If you refile for Chapter 7 after a previous Chapter 13 case was dismissed, you may not be able to keep secured property you were able to hold on to during the Chapter 13 proceedings.
- McDonald Law Offices: Dismissed Cases
- Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute: 11 USC 349, Effect of Dismissal
- United States Courts: Liquidation Under the Bankruptcy Code
- United States Courts: Individual Debt Adjustment
- Chapter13Info.com: Dismissal vs. Discharge
- Licker Law Firm LLC: How Can a Chapter 13 Bankruptcy Be Reinstated?
- Lee Law Firm: Reasons Why a Bankruptcy Case is Dismissed
A freelance writer since 1978 and attorney since 1981, Cindy Hill has won awards for articles on organic agriculture and wild foods, and has published widely in the areas of law, public policy, local foods and gardening. She holds a B.A. in political science from State University of New York and a Master of Environmental Law and a J.D. from Vermont Law School.